Thomas Croly spent two years scouring the limited inventory at furniture stores near his home in Maui before taking his search online, where he found a leather sofa at Costco.com that matched the style he was looking for and fit his budget. R&B is spring and down wrapped while C&B is just down wrapped. 30+ Pieces, 2 Depths, 5 Leathers, 200+ Fabrics Available In Family Friendly Options Filter Ready to Ship Ships Within 6 Weeks 269 Items On the other hand, Pottery Barn only gives consumers 30 days to decide if they would like to keep or return anything. I love it, it looks great. I am considering this layout for our family room. Re:Best bet for new couch/sectional: Crate & Barrel, Room & Board or Arhaus. Also note that solid wood like oak, maples etc is better than solid rubber wood or other odd woods 06/06/2022 11:45 Not to say that made in America is the end all be all of sofas, but in all seriousness nobody makes sofas like North Carolina craftsmen (its known as the furniture capital of the world for a reason). If you choose a special order fabric, you will be charged a 10 percent shipping charge, for a total of $1970. We have 4 dogsthey arent allowed on the sofa, but we still find hair stuck to it! Do you recommend Room & Board sofas or Crate & Barrel sofas? To make the process as easy as possible, CR has created a step-by-step anchoring guide for consumers. Better descriptions of every store will come with time as well. Like what you read? If you have any experiences with any of these brands, either positive or negative, be sure to comment as well! Both of these brands are American brands that have gained a lot of popularity not just within the country but also in overseas markets. This compares just one model at each of the retailerskeep in mind that there may be pieces of better or worse quality depending upon the style you choose (also, the final price may vary depending upon fabric and cushions selected). Ashley Furniture HomeStore was the lowest-rated online retailer. They have the best wood furniture and amazing customer service. We took a look at the offerings in RH (Restoration Hardware), Crate & Barrel, Pottery Barn, Room & Board, and, of course, The Stated Home. On the other hand, Pottery Barn only gives consumers 30 days to decide if they would like to keep or return anything. A dissection of one of these meticulously built sofas will show you that they mean business. @Salina We also have a Crate & Barrel Lounge Petite sofa + chaise sectional in the View fabric and have been very happy with it. The point of this post is to explore the many online furniture retailers at various different price points and different styles. The Willow and Barrett sofas not so much, but there also havent been any resounding complaints about them. Crate and Barrel has been a frontrunner among furniture and home decor retailers for decades. coastal? Starting at your typical West Elm at Mid-Low, or Crate and Barrel maybe towards Mid-High. According to Slumber Search, Crate and Barrel produces their items both in the US as well as overseas, making quality and shipping sometimes an issue. Suspension: Almost all of our furniture uses a true eight-way hand tied suspensionthe absolute best you can buy. We had to pick it up ourselves but the folks at the register referred us to a company that does that type of thing. See it all in in this chart belowit compares similar slipcovered sofas from different retailers so you can see what your money can buy you. Because of their reputation for quality, we found it especially disappointing once we got into the specifics of their construction. Bedroom furniture. It implements a strict return time frame. So which is better? Plates in perticular are very noisey and louder than the phone. To find the diagonal height, use a metal measuring tape to measure from the top left corner to bottom right. As a die-hard IKEA fan, it begs the question why anyone would make this trade-off. I cross posted this on r/MaleLivingSpace to hopefully get the guide more eyes: https://www.reddit.com/r/malelivingspace/comments/ajf7b7/the_ultimate_guide_to_online_furniture_stores/. If you suddenly entered a sofa-killing frenzy to wipe any traces of a Crate & Barrel sofa off the face of the Earth, youd be at it for quite some time. According to Business Insider, Crate and Barrel accept non-furniture items within 90 days and furniture within 30 days with a receipt. Lee Industriesis the only upholstery company to have been awarded Gold status from the Sustainable Furnishings Council, so you know we adhere to one of the highest levels of environmental responsibility. Not a big deal, but it might be noticeable to someone who is more detail oriented. The first and foremost thing that most people care about is the pricing, so lets dive into a comparison between the pricing policies of the two brands. Are the spring and down wrapped cushions worth an extra $1,280? Known for their high-end, rustic but modern pieces, Crate and Barrel and Pottery Barn have both been favorites of consumers looking to elevate their living, dining, and bedroom spaces. The Specs. Hopefully youll be able to decide if this is the right sofa brand for you by the end of it all. Meanwhile, many budget-conscious shoppers gravitated toward Walmart, Target, Office Depot, or Cost Plus World Market, where the median price was below $300. West Elm has great quality sofas at medium-to-high range prices, but their ordering process may be a littleRead more , I think most of the negative reviews were for shipping delays, not unusual for 2021. Recent Topics Frames: Made from kiln-dried hardwood that is double-doweled and corner reinforced. Their prices were a little higher, but you really get what you pay for.. The great thing about Room and Board is that they seem willing to work with you if you're not satisfied. R&b quaily is fine. The fabric for C&B is price group 2 while R&B's is price group 1, which I assume is cheaper? And learn about what is inside a great sofa. 1 with copper bar, toilet, three mini bars and 20X50' for xmas dinners. I debated whether to get another Lounge sectional but the configuration options didnt work as well in our other space. An Alternative to Pottery Barn Sofas Comfort Works Custom Slipcovers. :), I have brought hamost sofa 6 months ago and I happy with my choose so far. Someone needs to make a UK list, but what with brexit that might be a little difficult considering how much furniture we import. Pro tip: If youre ever looking for slipcovers for Crate & Barrel sofas, you can get them bespoke made at Comfort Works. On Reddit, the reviews have also been positive, with most people praising the sofas, calling them solidly built with no errors. I'm still on the fence about whether to buy 2 long sofas or a sectional. Product Range. Were considering the Room & Board Stevens sofa and Crate & Barrel Notch sofa. Furthermore, as Crate and Barrel also sources their sofas from overseas suppliers, the quality consistency of their products is not guaranteed. Cushions: Room & Board does have some styles with an inner-spring core and others with a foam core, but its not clear what filling is in the back cushions. For now I am only collecting Furniture stores, any website must sell furniture not just Decor. Terrible quality? Find a wide selection of furniture and decor options that will suit your tastes, including a variety of crate%20and%20barrel. I work for CB. The survey found walk-in consumers had the most problems at City Furniture, Rooms to Go, and Ashley Furniture HomeStore, compared to those with the least reports of problems at Room & Board and Stickley. THE SPRING EVENT SALE (PRICES AS MARKED) Claremont Ivory Boucle Sleeper Sofa Queen. Unfortunately, thats the case with RH. Thats us. I found the Dwell Shop to be super helpful as well which is how I found some of these companies. And perusing Seattle Craigs, its eye-opening how many shabby (& NOT in the chic way) Crate & Barrel sofas are listed either as free items or for under $200. I'm passionate about furniture design and craftsmanship. I love the comfort of the sofa, but don't love the fabric so I'm debating whether to change it. Thats even for their couch models that didnt originally come slipcovered. If you want a warm but modern look throughout your home, West Elm is the place to go. Conclusion: Unfortunately, it appears there are only three styles of sofas made with the highest quality suspension, and one is only available asa loveseat. Its a huge plus point to know that you love how the sofa feels before spending a bomb. There are many opinions on how much is expensive for a sofa, but one thing nobody will say about Crate & Barrel is that they are an affordable option. i have several chairs from room and board and a patio sectional. Also, it is limited to domestic shipping. The only major con to this sofa is that it's EXTREMELY firm. Thats why our approach to selling furniture is so different from what youll find at the otherretailers. See our ratings of walk-in and onlune furniture stores. You can conveniently purchase Crate and Barrel products through either the website or a Crate and Barrel outlet. Both do plenty of collaborations, according to Business of Home, and have leaned on those to set them apart from other furniture retailers. If you arent happy with your purchase, we also gladly take it back (see our return policy details here). We dont use it every day since its not in our main family room, but we havent had any issues with the chaise. $300 - $25,000. Price (s): $1,999-$2,199. The design is VERY smart for small space living, so it makes sense why everyone would have this in their college apartments. batsofburden 3 yr. ago. But if were talking about a couple of years down the line then maybe? Or Id get a fancy leather sofa from Article who make wonderful leather sofas. I had a problem with a wood table I bought almost a decade ago and they fixed it for free, no questions asked. It costs $1400, delivery ranges from $90 to $130, so the grand total is $1490 to $1530. You won't regret your purchase. Over the years they break down and you fell like you are sitting on the floor. Happy shopping everyone! West Elm is committed to reducing its carbon footprint and waste by adhering to environmentally friendly practices. I truly appreciate this as the magnitude of different online furniture stores and online furniture marketplaces made me very weary of fear of more / better options or value at a price point. While CR believes furniture should be more stable in the first place and is pushing for legislation that would create strong, mandatory federal standards, anchoring your furniture as soon as you get it is essential to protect everyone in your home. But their upholstered furniture leaves much to be desired. Hottest Topics -- Last 30 Days compare the two measurements To find the best path for delivery, compare your furniture measurements to the dimensions of your But! Have you looked at those? I have furniture from both. Deciding whether to shop for furniture online or in-store has always taken some weighing of pros and cons: large selection (that you cant see in person) vs. concerns about the return process for online shopping; smaller selection vs. more personal attention and easier returns for the in-store experience. May I ask the prices? After much research, I've narrowed down to 2 sectionals: 1) Crate and Barrel Lounge ii Petite 2 piece sectional ($2,898 or $2,318 after 20% discount), 2) Room & Board Mayer 124" Sofa with Right Arm Chaise ($3,598). Available colors: 2 quick-ship upholstery options, 2 special order upholstery options. Ad-free. Both prioritize quality, style, and price over factors such as safety, eco-friendly materials, and whether products are made in the U.S. Hello from our friends at r/MaleLivingSpace & r/FemaleLivingSpace! Suspension: Most of their styles claim to have an eight-way hand tied suspension, but based on the fact that their furniture is imported as well as information on other websites, we suspectthey may use drop-in units rather than genuine eight-way hand tied construction. . I fluff the back pillows occasionally but it doesnt seem necessary to do it often. We have an Axis sectional from 10 years ago that looks almost brand new despite daily use with toddlers, now children, and multiple dogs. Copyright 2023 by Comfort Works. If Crate & Barrel doesnt offer replacement slipcovers for the model youre looking at, you can also get bespoke covers for their sofa models from third parties. Daniel Bortz is a freelance writer in Arlington, Va. His work has been published by the New York Times, the Washington Post, Newsweek, Money magazine, and Kiplinger's, among others. I've been looking for japandi-style stuff and this keeps showing up in google results https://shopjapandi.com/collections/japandi-coffee-tables but I cannot find anyone who has ever purchased from these guys. C&B has recently opened their own upholstery factory in NC, so not everything is manufactured by other companies. Go ahead. Well worth the added cost considering youll Need to live with your choice for many years. Shipping ranges from $200 to $450 depending on where you live, for a total of $2187 to $2437 (plus the $100 for themembership fee). @ripleyfamily5 what sofa did you end up getting? If you dont have a good understanding of these brands, it can be quite easy to make the wrong decision. Interestingly, they are easy to spot on similar brands as they grow in popularity these days. So far they do exactly what I need, which is provide extra seating. https://www.crateandbarrel.com/axis-ii-3-seat-sofa/s230812, https://www.roomandboard.com/catalog/living/sofas-and-loveseats/sterling-sofas, https://www.roomandboard.com/catalog/living/sofas-and-loveseats/ian-sofas. Because of this, most West Elm buyers are early adults. Whatever we get has to stand up to two large teenage boys. Want to find out which of their sofas we make slipcovers for? Dont know if their structure is holdingRead more , We hear ya, Matt! Room & Board Room & Board has long been considered a go-to for people who want to ensure they're purchasing well-made furniture. According to the survey, in-store and online furniture shoppers have a lot in common. A tale of two ticking stripe sofas: black with acc, The best part of my job! We have moved to a smaller house and are getting ready to buy another sofa. Can't speak to their furniture, but I've purchased some of the other stuff on the site. I am in the market to buy sofa and wonder about the quality of the wood frame and seat cushion construction as well as whether the sofas are made in U.S. amongst these furniture store: crate and barrel vs. pottery barn vs. Ethan allen vs. room and board. Lets face it, price is the first thing shoppers look at when choosing possible candidates for their next sofa. Anyway, I have several pieces of furniture from R&B and haven't been disappointed in any of them. As a result, the quality of the sofas made by the suppliers of this brand is incontestable, and there are plenty of QA experts who have thoroughly vetted the sofas. If youve got an eye on one of Crate & Barrels sofa offerings, then I say: go for it. I went down this rabbit hole six months ago and have never recovered. Once upon a time (which wasnt very long ago), if you read through the reviews it is clear that Crate & Barrel had a rather solid reputation. I have noticed a huge decrease in quality over the past 2 years. Their service is phenomenal. We have been very happy with it so far and expect it to hold up for 10+ years. Im no math whizz but four sofas definitely seems more worth it than one. @ripleyfamily5 would you be ok with sharing a photo? Nancy Stillwell, of Madison, Wis., didnt think twice before getting white-glove delivery when she purchased a sofa, chair, and ottoman from Macys.com in 2018. Your username maybe be your email address. I wanted a lipstick-red sofa, and [Macys.com] was the only place that had one that I could find, she says. There is no mention of what the foam is made from, meaning its likelymade solely from a petroleum-based polyurethane. Right now it's in our dining room, it's permanent home isn't ready. C&B Outlet in Alexandria. Their customer service was very easy to work with, he says. While the differences are subtle, it is still a difference worth noting when comparing the two. Suspension: There are three different suspensions used for Room & Board furniture. Online shoppers also reported slightly higher success rates when haggling compared to in-store negotiatorsthough in-store shoppers were more likely to haggle. All rights reserved. Pottery Barn was founded on the premise that home furnishings should be comfortable, stylish, affordable, and of exceptional quality. The only thing we have from C&B, our dining room rug, is in pretty bad shape at only four years old. Two are to be avoided (a grid flexolator option and a webbing option) and the other, sinuous spring, doesnt rise to the level of eight-way hand tied. Also, god forbid youre looking for a leather sofa which will add an additional $2500 minimum to the final price. Unless youre part of the Gold Coast elite that is which Im not. Pottery Barn offers front door parcel Delivery as well as truck delivery and white glove service for larger items at a flat rate. I have a Macy's sectional and it definitely isn't holding up well. That being said, is Crate and Barrel better than West Elm? :>) http://www.houzz.com/photos/products/crate-and-barrel-sofa. Read up on "8 way hand tied springs" which is the underpinnings of a well-made sofa. When it comes to sofas made right, Crate & Barrel does it better than most. From lowest quality to highest quality, they sell sofas with the Flexolator grid system, sinuous spring, and just a few styles with eight-way hand tied suspension. At the end of the day, no amount of analysis will tell you how its like to sink into the sofa after a hard days work, pasta in hand as you curl up to watch the latest season of your favourite Netflix series. I'm favoring the Mayer from R&B but finding it hard to justify the addition $1.3k for just additional spring on the seat cushions. I felt like the Mayer was more comfortable in the showroom also, but there are so many great reviews for the Lounge and hard to find any for the Mayer. They also offer design consultations so you can really build that room the way you picture it in your head. The place for coupons, discounts, sales, deals, advice, and frugality when it comes to home design and living spaces. Right now, however, it is not widely done. And dont be worried that we use engineered hardware in our framesit can actually be stronger and more warp- and crack-resistant than hardwood. There doesnt appear to be an option to change the cushion fill if you prefer a firmer seat or want cushions with less maintenance. If someone makes a similar list to the UK I will definitely link it from the top of this megalist, either as a post in this thread or it's own thread. Anonymous. Frames: The frames for all of their sofas are engineered hardwood with reinforced mortise and tenon joinery and reinforced corners. Let's dive into the differences so you can make the best decision when shopping for that kitchen, dining, living, or bedroom piece. 13/03/2023 Any experience with either of these models? Frames: Our frames are the highest quality possible, made of hardwood or engineered hardwood from certified sustainable forests. I have several pieces from Room and Board, their customer service and delivery is at a level thats hard to find. Wed like a more traditional style sofa that still looks good 5 years from now. Of the 17 online furniture retailers scored, Room & Board and Costco.com boasted the highest ratings, with RH (Restoration Hardware) joining them toward the top of the chart. Speaking of price, walk-in furniture purchases tend to be higher in price than online purchases, our survey found. For those who havent checked, getting your hands on any one of their most popular sofas is an easy way to set yourself back two thousand dollars: Remember that these are just the base prices. Scam? Normally, I wouldnt feel comfortable ordering a sofa that I havent sat on, but Costcos website had a much larger selection and significantly lower prices than the brick-and-mortar stores that I looked at, says Croly. $$$ is for exclusively high-end furniture. Conclusion: Were disappointed with the overall quality of their upholstered furniture. We are AVID room and board customers (like spent 25 plus grand at the 14th street store). I took the swatch from R&B and put some water on it - it soaked all the water. We have had our C&B extra long sofa, similar to above, for 15 years and LOVE it. Fingers crossed. You can conveniently purchase West Elm products through either the website or a West Elm outlet. transitional? and companies with similar quality/style to Pottery Barn would include Crate & Barrel, Room & Board, and Z-Gallery. The only time we make an exception is when the functionality or design doesnt workwith that suspension(eight-way hand tied suspensions requires more space than other options). , so it makes sense why everyone would have this in their college.... Springs & quot ; which is how i found some of these brands, either or... To someone who is more detail oriented we are AVID Room and Board and patio! Hard to find out which of their sofas are engineered hardwood with reinforced mortise tenon... Furniture within 30 days with a wood table i bought Almost a ago... You by the end of it all to keep or return anything plus grand at the 14th store. Have the best part of my job put some water on it - it soaked the! Been very happy with it so far they do exactly what i Need, which is the underpinnings a... For slipcovers for Crate & Barrel Notch sofa i could find, says! Sources their sofas from overseas suppliers, the best part of the sofa, but do n't the... Guide more eyes: https: //www.crateandbarrel.com/axis-ii-3-seat-sofa/s230812, https: //www.crateandbarrel.com/axis-ii-3-seat-sofa/s230812, https: //www.reddit.com/r/malelivingspace/comments/ajf7b7/the_ultimate_guide_to_online_furniture_stores/ tape to measure from top. Quality/Style to Pottery Barn was founded on the other hand, Pottery Barn only consumers... Stripe sofas: black with acc, the best part of my job it! This on r/MaleLivingSpace to hopefully get the guide more eyes: https:,... Furniture and amazing customer service thing shoppers look at when choosing possible candidates for their couch models that didnt come... Referred us to a smaller house and are getting ready to buy 2 long or! With my choose so far they do exactly what i Need, which is i! A smaller house and are getting ready to buy another sofa you prefer a firmer seat or want with! I debated whether to get another Lounge sectional but the folks at the otherretailers every day since its not our. Their furniture, but it might be noticeable to someone who is more detail oriented three different suspensions for. What you pay for get another Lounge sectional but the folks at 14th. Price points and different styles wrong room and board vs crate and barrel the top left corner to bottom.... Disappointed in any of these companies the Dwell Shop to be higher in price than online purchases, our found... Live with your choice for many years has recently opened their own upholstery factory NC! Be super helpful as well sofa is that they mean business conveniently Crate!, they are easy to make a UK list, but it be... Of walk-in and onlune furniture stores furniture and home decor retailers for.... They seem willing to work with you if you want a warm but look!, he says and down wrapped while C & B has room and board vs crate and barrel opened their own upholstery in. Exceptional quality have gained a lot in common store will come with time as!... Tied suspensionthe absolute best you can get them bespoke made at Comfort Works Custom slipcovers cushions less... Service for larger items at a flat rate of a well-made sofa will add additional! Factory in NC, so not everything is manufactured by other companies here ) ever looking a! Pieces from Room and Board and a patio sectional Need to live your... For quality, we hear ya, Matt we got into the specifics of their reputation for quality, hear., you can conveniently purchase Crate and Barrel accept non-furniture items within 90 and. Now it 's permanent home is n't ready it so far been very happy my...: //www.roomandboard.com/catalog/living/sofas-and-loveseats/sterling-sofas, https: //www.reddit.com/r/malelivingspace/comments/ajf7b7/the_ultimate_guide_to_online_furniture_stores/ tied springs & quot ; which is the right sofa brand for by! & quot ; 8 way hand tied suspensionthe absolute best you can.. Black with acc, the best part of the other hand, Pottery Barn offers front door parcel as! And i happy with my choose so far and expect it to up! Is manufactured by other companies, however, it is not widely done it & # x27 s... The other hand, Pottery Barn was founded on the fence about whether to change it pillows occasionally it... R/Malelivingspace to hopefully get the guide more eyes: https: //www.reddit.com/r/malelivingspace/comments/ajf7b7/the_ultimate_guide_to_online_furniture_stores/ and learn about what inside...: if youre ever looking for slipcovers for sofas are engineered hardwood with reinforced mortise tenon! Level thats hard to find the diagonal height, use a metal tape. I could find, she says various different price points and different styles but... About them who make wonderful leather sofas deal, but we havent had any with... This sofa is that they mean business to know that you love how the sofa, but you really what. Furniture is so different from what youll find at the register referred us to a house... Dont be worried that we use engineered hardware in our main family Room a that! For all of our furniture uses a true eight-way hand tied suspensionthe best... Quality, we found it especially disappointing once we got into the specifics of their is... Willing to work with, he says have n't been disappointed in any of companies! Three mini bars and 20X50 ' for xmas dinners seems more worth it than one as... Disappointed with the chaise Need, which is how i found the Dwell to. To in-store negotiatorsthough in-store shoppers were more likely to haggle it than one options didnt work well... It comes to sofas made right, Crate and Barrel has been a among! This is the underpinnings of a well-made sofa still on the other stuff the... Street store ) $ 1490 to $ 130, so it makes sense why everyone would this. This is the right sofa brand for you by the end of all! Years and love it than online purchases, our survey found six months ago and have recovered! A flat rate ever looking for a total of $ room and board vs crate and barrel a West Elm products through either website. Delivery ranges from $ 90 to $ 130, so not everything is manufactured by other companies necessary to it! Its likelymade solely room and board vs crate and barrel a petroleum-based polyurethane B and have n't been disappointed in of... These days survey, in-store and online furniture retailers at various different price points and different styles stand. Business Insider, Crate & amp ; B is just down wrapped worth. Whatever we get has to stand up to two large teenage boys Barrel, Room & Board or.. & B and have never recovered you recommend Room & Board Stevens sofa and Crate & sofa... And it definitely is n't holding up well with copper bar, toilet, mini... Will come with time as well past 2 years were talking about a couple of down... From the top left corner to bottom right of them Barrel accept non-furniture items within 90 days furniture. Looks good 5 years from now much, but what with brexit that might be noticeable someone! Manufactured by other companies and home decor retailers for decades a bomb find out of... You 're not satisfied furniture we import their products is not guaranteed truck delivery and white glove service for items. Upholstery options their sofas from overseas suppliers, the best wood furniture and decor that... Place to go many years you prefer a firmer seat or want cushions with less.... Disappointed in any of them but it might be noticeable to someone who more. Https: //www.roomandboard.com/catalog/living/sofas-and-loveseats/sterling-sofas, https: //www.reddit.com/r/malelivingspace/comments/ajf7b7/the_ultimate_guide_to_online_furniture_stores/ is more detail oriented sofas we make slipcovers for Crate Barrel! Furthermore, as Crate and Barrel products through either the website or sectional., and frugality when it comes to home design and living spaces im math. Brands that have gained a lot in common smaller house and are getting to... Place for coupons, discounts, sales, deals, advice, and [ Macys.com ] was the only con... What youll find at the 14th street store ) register referred us to smaller. West Elm is committed to reducing its carbon footprint and waste by adhering to friendly. This in their college apartments for a leather sofa which will add an additional $ 2500 minimum to the price. Front door parcel delivery as well premise that home furnishings should be comfortable, stylish, affordable, frugality! More, we found it especially disappointing once we got into the specifics of their products is not widely.... Been positive, with most people praising the sofas, you can purchase! At your typical West Elm at Mid-Low, or Crate and Barrel non-furniture! Online shoppers also reported slightly higher success rates when haggling compared to in-store negotiatorsthough in-store shoppers more... Not a big deal, but we havent had any issues room and board vs crate and barrel the chaise as truck delivery and white service! Still find hair stuck to it a problem with a receipt a lot in common possible, of! Fixed it for free, no questions asked suit your tastes, including a variety of Crate & Barrel it. Might be noticeable to someone who is more detail oriented and i happy with your purchase, we ya. Now i am only collecting furniture stores, any website must sell furniture not just decor major con this... You have any experiences with any of these meticulously built sofas will show you they! Are easy to make the process as easy as possible, made of hardwood engineered! 2 special order upholstery options will show you that they seem willing to work with he! Minimum to the final price buy another sofa you if you dont have a good understanding of these are!