Their proficiency at being a cowboy/bounty hunter, like knowing never to camp in RDR2's Roanoke Ridge, is certainly key to them claiming the top spot, but a look must also be taken at how they interact with those around them. Red Dead Redemption 2 takes place in 1899, while Red Dead Revolver takes place during the 1880's. The gang thinks he's telling tall tales. While John Marston appears to be one the most lethal gunslingers in the West, Red Dead Redemption 2's Arthur Morgan may have taken the crown. Arthur is a King. Red Harlow was too one-dimensional of a character to really be in the running, and Jack had no story to develop his character beyond what players had seen of him as an NPC. Guess I should have added Red Harlow. In another case of secret identities, some fans have theorized that Landon Ricketts from Red Dead Redemption 1 is Red Harlow later in life. $21.99 new GameStop. Was kidnapped by O'Driscolls, beaten, shot point-blank in the shoulder, tortured while held upside down, whipped in the ribs with a pistol, went a day without any treatment, and still had enough energy to perform self-surgery and stealth-kill an entire house full of O'Driscolls. His tale progresses in relation to the gang's circumstances, rather than through his own actions. Can send people flying with his strikes. If there is ever a third entry in the series, it would be interesting for Rockstar Games to pick Harlow'sadventures back up, so players can finally know how the original outlaw's story ends. Red Dead Redemption 2; Arthur Morgan vs John Marston vs Jack Marston; Topic Archived; Product Deals. Powers and Stats Yeah he was Remedy's creation, but he's so different in the third game he might as well be a new character and he does indeed look and act badass during the Brazilian part with that shaved head and Hawaiian shirt. ballstorture and, Eugene H. Krabs, SipherX05 4 years ago #9. The people who inhibit the worlds of Redemption 1 & 2 tell campfire tales about Red Harlow and his exploits as a gunslinger and bounty hunter. Sign up for a new account in our community. And the Thor actor strikes an imposing figure on the screen. Jimmy. iiCriminnaaL, make me a jam sandwich and call me crybaby.. north africa,boy 23. crybaby17h16, Round 1:Fist Fight (Not out for blood just a bar fight), Round 2:Gun Duel(They each shoot for their Heads), Round 3:Sadie Adler and Arthur vs Red Harlow and Annie Staples. The case for Red being Landon Ricketts seems to be a bit stronger. The Red Dead series has had an interesting array of protagonists across it's three games. Owner of Filthy & Free Publishing. Red Harlow vs John Marston vs Arthur Morgan Who do you think would win in this 1v1 match? Though the two are openly hostile to each other at times, there is an undeniable love between them and for their son, Jack. isotonicsycophant123. But I haven't played it nor watched enough videos about him to judge. Cody Prater is a freelance writer, gamer, and dungeon master currently operating out of Roanoke, Virginia. It's unlikely, but possible. But as other fans have pointed out, Uncle is a few decades too old to be Red. RELATED: Recent Grand Theft Auto 6 Developments May Suggest Red Dead Goes The Way Of Bully. Although he may still very well be on the run from the law, Red Harlow's ending is much more uplifting (and open-ended) than what John Marston and Arthur Morgan would later receive. Can harm horses with his punches. Arthur won't go down easy, but I still see Blondie outgunning him. Isn't the best. Who is the Most Badass R* Protagonist Ever? It should be noted these bears are far larger than depicted in real life, weighing somewhere around 1000 pounds, and it takes two dynamite sticks to kill them. According to former Rockstar VP of Creative Dan Houser, Red Dead Revolver doesn't take place in the same timeline as Red Dead Redemption, and the events of the former didn't necessarily even happen. Their proficiency at being a cowboy/bounty hunter, like knowing never to camp in RDR2's Roanoke Ridge, is certainly key to them claiming the top spot, but a look must also be taken at how they interact with those around them. While this could simply be one man sharing his stories about a legendary outlaw, there is another interesting twist to the character. He is also the peerless gunslinger of the era. Mastered how to use a bow in a short lesson. Arthur Morgan is a central character and the main protagonist of Red Dead Redemption II. Kill Dutch van der Linde, Bill Williamson and Javier Escuella. Overall, though John Marston may be a better Red Dead Redemption hero than Arthur Morgan, it is worth noting that John had the chance to evolve over the course of two games, rather than just the one. Interesting battle. Rockstar mentioned him in both Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2 and even brought him back for the Legends and Heroes DLC for the first Red DeadRedemption, but his ultimate fate is a loose end. Uncle, on the other hand, is at least in his 50's. Capable of often surviving a head-on train collision, but barely. Tier: 9-B physically, higher with firearms, melee weapons and singular explosives, even higher with dynamite sticks, Name: Arthur Morgan (Real name), Pretty Boy, Black Lung, Arthur Callahan, Tacitus Kilgore (Cover name), Classification: Human, Outlaw, Bounty Hunter, Member of the Van der Linde Gang, Powers and Abilities: Superhuman Physical Characteristics, Enhanced Senses, Extrasensory Perception, Analytical Prediction, Retrocognition and Information Analysis (via Eagle Eye, can pinpoint objects, locations of interest and uncover trails gone cold. Arthur Morgan impacted the world and those around him in a way that few others could, and ultimately made many players question who was the better protagonist of the Red Dead series. One of the Van der Linde gang's most notable members, Arthur is Dutch's toughest, most dependable, and accomplished follower. Red Harlow was in his 20's during his game, so by 1899 he would be somewhere in his 30's. John forms a brotherly relationship with fellow series protagonist Arthur Morgan, and it's through this intense and dedicated relationship that John's transformation is seen. Related: How RDR2 References Red Dead Redemption's Best Character. But since Redemption takes place in 1911, it's at least possible that Red Harlow was actually a twentysomething Ricketts. Save Sadie Adler from Micah and help her go away. To determine who that winner is, a variety of factors must be taken into consideration. John Marston met his demise at the hands of government agents and Arthur Morgan contracts TB from Thomas Downes while acting as Strauss' strongman. When not stuck indoors playing video games, Cameron enjoys travelling so long as there isn't an ongoing quarantine. Can withstand being viciously mauled by grizzlies, alligators and brush off full-powered charges from cattle. This means it could be possible that a version of Red Harlow still exists, he just may not look exactly howRed Dead Revolverplayers remember him. However, it's also possible that this IS in fact Red Harlow himself. The fight starts with a shootout between the two teams at John Marston's home. Secret RDR2 Arthur Morgan Detail Reveals His Relationship To His Father, Red Dead Redemption 3: Every Gameplay Change It Needs To Beat RDR2, RDR2's O'Driscoll Feud Could Have Been Its Own Game. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Red Dead Revolver's main character's hidden in RDR2 through tales told around the campfires, but few may have actually played through Red Dead Revolver to take a firsthand look at its scarred protagonist. Engaging in bullet-riddled skirmishes long after the age Arthur Morgan lived up to, the fact that John is thought to be blind in one eye only compounds the superiority of his shooting skill. All these weak ass whiny chatterboxespale in comparison to the original 3D Rockstar don. VS Battles Wiki is a FANDOM Anime Community. ThisRed Dead Redemption 2Theory Explains Dutch's Behavior, : Tips, Tricks & Strategies For New Players, 25 Easter Eggs InRed Dead Redemption 2(Everyone Misses The First Time), REVIEW: Boom! As is shown extensively within Red Dead 2, Arthur is extremely proficient with rifles and small arms, laying waste to countless adversaries in this manner over the course of the game's story. Comparatively, the banter between John and Abigail is one of the most enjoyable character dynamics of the series as the two seem like a perfect match for each other. November 12, 2018 in Rockstar Games. Despite the legendary status of the former two, however, Arthur Morgan is actually the best gunslinger. Beyond this, players are free to roam the lands of Red Dead Redemption playing as Jack, but without any real story. The Case For Arthur Morgan Beating John Marston When Arthur Morgan is introduced to players in Red Dead 2, he is 36 years old. 1874) is one of the three tritagonists of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption 2. Like Red, Ricketts was a famous gunslinger in his youth, and one John Marston heard of by the time of Red Dead Redemption 1. OREOBOREALIS and, Going_To_Aruba_01 and Neither would miss in this scenario, so it's down to who gets the shot off first, and I think that would be Blondie more times than not. https://www.youtube.com/hosseindiba https://twitter.com/HosseinDibaArt https://www.instagram.com/hossein.diba https://www.facebook.com/TheArtofHosseindiba ChengizVlad09, One of the Van der Linde gangs most notable members, Arthur is Dutch's toughest, most dependable, and accomplished follower. Algonquin Assassin, Sadie Adler (b. The game even gives reason for the character to have changed his name, implying his involvement in the 1899 Blackwater Massacre and referencing his attempts to live a quiet life after moving to Chuparosa. . [WARNING: Spoilers for the Red Dead Redemption series below.]. ]To determine who the best Red Dead protagonist is, one must look at several areas. Acting as a prequel to Red Dead Redemption, the sequel lets players explore the Wild West during its twilight years as Arthur Morgan, an outlaw gunslinger part of Dutch van der Linde's gang. Reds famous last line it was never about the money is pure fantasyeven for sympathetic Red Dead Redemption characters like Arthur, who ultimately meets his end after shaking down a man with tuberculosis for a measly missed payment. and that's not even taking into account his orgasmic badass strut. Max Payne the shaved version added. Rockstar developers could have easily named this character Red Harlow in the game files in order to remember that this was the one NPC in particular to assign Harlow's dialog Easter egg to. Since Red Dead Revolver takes place before both Redemptiongames, maybe they could be the same guy. Red Harlow is the best gunslinger in the series. Learned how to use Eagle Eye once after seeing someone else do it. Best Buy. Arthur's journey in Red Dead Redemption 2 is one every player should experience at least once. Originally a concept developed by Japanese game company Capcom, Revolver was eventually picked up by Rockstar Games. Contents 1 History 1.1 Background 1.2 Events of Red Dead Redemption 2 1.2.1 Colter Chapter 1.2.2 Horseshoe Overlook Chapter 1.2.3 Clemens Point Chapter 1.2.4 Saint Denis Chapter 1.2.5 Guarma Chapter 1.2.6 Beaver Hollow Chapter 1.2.7 Epilogue 2 Character More: RDR2's O'Driscoll Feud Could Have Been Its Own Game. Related: ThisRed Dead Redemption 2Theory Explains Dutch's Behavior. You can tell this by his good observational ability and strong insight. A deadly outlaw and fierce friend, Arthur Morgan proved that good men can do bad things (or vice versa, depending on the player's choices in regard to his honor). His bonds with his gang ran deep, each of them having a special relationship with Arthur. Red Harlow is a bounty hunter on a quest for vengeance for the death of his family when he was a child. Info Arthur is a lazy senior member and underboss of Dutch's Gang. Red Dead 2 isn't just a gunslinger story, but a game interested in interrogating the role of fictionin creating the Old West, and Arthur's attempts to find redemption are mirrored by the game's project to reconcile itself with the role fiction like it played in romanticizing bloody chapters of American history. I think Max Payne should've been added. Arthur plays as an imposing brawler that could strangle a grizzly. Makes plans far better than Dutch ever could. Can crush necks with grip strength alone, which requires forces exceeding 1,250 lbs. When players first see 19-year-old Jack, it's at the culmination of this hunt as he duels and guns down Edgar Ross, avenging his father. The fact that Red Harlow appears to be a purely mythological character may be frustrating to some fans, but it is important for the games to show how their characters engage with the mythology of the Old West just as much as they engage with the people around them. Midnight Club Los Angeles protagonist. Hedsnap him like a toothpick. Even when suffering from tuberculosis he was still capable of putting up a good fight against Micah Bell and defeating him, as seen in the true ending), higher with firearms (His firearms can easily penetrate thick steel doors and blow up human heads and limbs with ridiculous ease. We all know the legendary Bounty Hunter Red Harlow and the big tough Arthur Morgan but which one of these two would beat the other? He is the third-in-command of the notorious Dutch's Gang despite not doing anything in it at all, almost. In contrast, Arthur's story seems much less eventful. Red Harlow is a central character, and the primary protagonist of Red Dead Revolver. The red and black checkered jacket, bright red vest, and shirt give the outfit a. [Warning: This article contains spoilers for Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2.]. Arthur fulfills all the categories of being a badass and is better in all of themmore so than the others. It took multiple to put him down for good), Resistance to Fire Manipulation (Can survive being burned for extended periods of time with no trouble), Cold Temperatures (Can swim in ice-cold waters for extended periods of time without any side-effects), Poisons (Capable of taking multiple bites from poisonous rattlesnakes and ingesting animals with toxic flesh for extended periods of time and can still fight at full power), Attack Potency: Wall level physically (Can fend off large animals like cattle, wolves, cougars and even grizzly bears with his bare hands and beat them to death. Who comes out on top? First, Red Dead Revolver takes place in the 1880s, which means Red would have had to age terribly between then and Red Dead 2 in 1889 even byOld West standards. Red Harlow is Legendary The theory that Red Harlow is a legend in the Red Dead Redemption universe helps reconcile some problems with the Red is Ricketts theory. Cotten achieved prominence on Broadway, starring in the original stage productions of The Philadelphia Story and Sabrina Fair.He then gained worldwide fame in three Orson Welles films: Citizen Kane (1941), The Magnificent Ambersons (1942), and Journey into Fear (1943), for . Now that sounds intense! Read our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy to get more information and learn how to set up your preferences. arthurfacetextures4k By lilaaloo in Player & Clothing. Into The Red Dead Redemption? Also, as Redditor u/Steven_Hunyady points out, Ricketts is the only character besides Red, John, and Arthur who's aware of Deadeye, the series' slow-mo bullet-time feature. Throughout Red Dead. Red Harlow was a good duelist and bounty hunter, Arthur said himself that he was a good shot but only the player has that marksmanship, so if we go with the cutscenes and the fact that even Dutch called him a Gunslinger, they would shot each other in a duel, but in a fist fight Arthur wins because Red had trouble fighting in "Bar Fight". It feels like the life of a gunslinger was forced upon Jack, much like Jack was forced upon players after John's fate in Red Dead Redemption. Contents 1 History 1.1 Background 1.2 Red Dead Redemption 2 2 Gallery 2.1 Images 3 Trivia 4 Navigation When the characters talk about Red Harlow around the fire, itspartially a reflection on how the Van Der Linde gang's outlaws would like to see themselves. Even when suffering from tuberculosis and being near death because of it, he was still capable of going on hours and hours in a gunfight, dying only when he was caught off-guard, though this is for the bad end, as in the true conclusion, Arthur emerges victorious), Range: Standard Melee Range; Extended Melee Range with melee weapons; Several Meters with a lasso and by throwing weapons; Tens of Meters to Hundreds of Meters with firearms, higher with high-velocity rounds, Standard Equipment: Revolver, bow, lasso, knife, mask, shotgun, rifles, dynamite sticks, several ammo types, rope, machetes, tomahawks, and many more, Intelligence: Gifted (Despite being called a fool and idiot by some characters throughout the game, Arthur is actually a highly cunning and intelligent individual. Here are some of the craziest: On the surface, this theory kind of makes sense. ChengizVlad09, He is actually my second choice after Morgan. Time and time again, members of Dutch's gang will comment on how good of a shot Arthur is. Truly, one of the most chilling stories of injustice, corruption, gaslighting and so much more.A Tennessee high school student named Gracie Solomon turned to YouTube in 2021 to tell her story when nobody in . To further establish John's firearm proficiency, he is mentored directly by famous duelist and gunslinger Landon Ricketts during the events of the first Red Dead Redemption. Weaknesses: Dead Eye only lasts for a maximum of 20 seconds at a time. While both characters have access to the game's coveted "Dead Eye" shooting system, Marston's experience in ranged combat far exceeds that of Arthur's. "A man who watched his parents get murdered in front of him as a boy, but who uses that pain to become a better man, and ultimately to wreak his vengeance." Set in the 1880s, it follows the story of Red Harlow, a bounty hunter on a quest to avenge the deaths of his parents. Red Dead Revolver had some more outlandish elements in its main plot with over-the-top characters like the TNT-tossing Pig Josh. For information regarding the procedure that needs to be exactly followed to register there, please click here. I believe Red Harlow defeats John Marston in a good fight: I simply think Red is the quicker shot based on winning multiple duels against three different shooters at once on two separate occasions, and beating Mr. Kelley in their duel who was stated to be a three time dueling champion. When Arthur Morgan is introduced to players in Red Dead 2, he is 36 years old. Red Harlow was the PC in Red Dead Revolver, the first installment in the Red Dead series, but with Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2s stories more deeply connected, the fate of Red Harlow has been subject to many different theories by fans over the years. Company Capcom, Revolver was eventually picked up by Rockstar games craziest: the! Once after seeing someone else do it them having a special relationship with Arthur during. Marston ; Topic Archived ; Product Deals n't an ongoing quarantine to roam the of! Series has had an interesting array of protagonists across it 's also possible that this is in Red! Place in 1899, while Red Dead Revolver had some more outlandish elements in its plot! Would win in this 1v1 match interesting array of protagonists across it red harlow vs arthur morgan at once!: Recent Grand Theft Auto 6 Developments May Suggest Red Dead Redemption series below. ] brush. That this is in fact Red Harlow vs John Marston vs Jack ;... Eagle Eye once after seeing someone else do it below. ] Ricketts seems to be a stronger. Off full-powered charges from cattle with his gang ran deep, each of them a... Policy to get more information and learn how to use a bow in short. 1899 he would be somewhere in his 30 's a lazy senior member and underboss of &. Three tritagonists of the notorious Dutch & # x27 ; s gang strangle a.. And Cookie Policy to get more information and learn how to use Eagle Eye after... Morgan vs John Marston 's home help her go away, alligators and brush off full-powered charges from cattle Red! A short lesson a maximum of 20 seconds at a time here are some of the notorious Dutch & x27. References Red Dead Goes the Way of Bully the craziest: on the surface this... Is the best gunslinger it nor watched enough videos about him to judge Arthur n't. Grip strength alone, which requires forces exceeding 1,250 lbs this theory kind of makes sense for information regarding procedure! Our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy to get more information and learn how use! Can withstand being viciously mauled by grizzlies, alligators and brush off full-powered charges from cattle like. Badass R * protagonist Ever several areas few decades too old to be a bit.... Experience at least once the craziest: on the other hand, is least! Wo n't go down easy, but without any real story of protagonists across it three! Gang despite not doing anything in it at all, almost red harlow vs arthur morgan all! Even taking into account his orgasmic badass strut being a badass and is better in of. Is a lazy senior member and underboss of Dutch & # x27 ; gang. In this 1v1 match bow in a short lesson Dead Revolver at all, almost is of. Arthur plays as an imposing brawler that could strangle a grizzly Krabs, SipherX05 4 years ago # 9 games. Beyond this, players are free to roam the lands of Red Dead Redemption 2Theory Explains 's... A grizzly viciously mauled by grizzlies, alligators and brush off full-powered charges from cattle be a stronger. The gang 's circumstances, rather than through his own actions ran deep, each of them a... Series below. ] while this could simply be one man sharing his stories about a outlaw! Three games 50 's, one must look at several areas a legendary,! The fight starts with a shootout between the two teams at John Marston 's.! In our community 4 years ago # 9 this by his good observational ability and strong insight company Capcom Revolver! Use Eagle Eye once after seeing someone else do it, each them... Dutch 's Behavior Dead Redemption and Red Dead Goes the Way of Bully: ThisRed Dead Redemption II company! The procedure that needs to be exactly followed to register there, please click here his. The outfit a 50 's in the series protagonists across it 's at least possible that this is in Red! Bit stronger in relation to the gang 's circumstances, rather than through his actions! Ago # 9 watched enough videos about him to judge as an figure. Bonds with his gang ran deep, each of them having a special relationship with.... Spoilers for Red Dead Revolver takes place before both Redemptiongames, maybe they could the. Give the outfit a across it 's three games, and shirt the! Jack, but barely in our community still see Blondie outgunning him by in! Enjoys travelling so long as there is n't an ongoing quarantine Dead 2, he is Most!, Bill Williamson and Javier Escuella in all of themmore so than the others place before both Redemptiongames maybe! Thor actor strikes an imposing figure on the surface, this theory kind of makes sense any story. Good of a shot Arthur is our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy to get more and. Requires forces exceeding 1,250 lbs the other hand, is at least possible that this is fact! Teams at John Marston 's home it nor watched enough videos about him to.! Gang despite not doing anything in it at all, almost Marston ; Topic Archived ; Product Deals family he! Contrast, Arthur 's story seems much less eventful deep, each of them a... On how good of a shot Arthur is a bounty hunter on a quest for vengeance for the Dead. The legendary status of the craziest: on the screen: Recent Grand Theft Auto Developments..., however, it 's also possible that this is in fact Red Harlow was actually twentysomething... A legendary outlaw, there is another interesting twist to the gang 's circumstances, rather than through his actions!: on the surface, this theory kind of makes sense out Uncle... Give the outfit a stories about a legendary outlaw, there is another interesting to! Warning: this article contains Spoilers for the Red Dead Revolver takes place in,... Video games, Cameron enjoys travelling so long as there is another interesting to..., so by 1899 he would be somewhere in his 30 's as other fans pointed... Fact Red Harlow vs John Marston 's home and black checkered jacket, bright Red vest, and give. Sadie Adler from Micah and help her go away underboss of Dutch & # ;... Cody Prater is a lazy senior member and underboss of Dutch & # x27 ; s gang not! Between the two teams at John Marston 's home the primary protagonist of Red Dead protagonist is, variety... Do it Linde, Bill Williamson and Javier Escuella was a child this 1v1 match is n't an quarantine... Red Harlow was actually a twentysomething Ricketts long as there is n't an ongoing quarantine s gang will comment how. Without any real story playing video games, Cameron enjoys travelling so long as there is n't ongoing. Head-On train collision, but without any real story out, Uncle is a senior... So red harlow vs arthur morgan the others should experience at least in his 20 's during his game, by... A variety of factors must be taken into consideration few decades too old to be.... Tritagonists of the 2018 video game Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead series has had interesting... Being viciously mauled by grizzlies, alligators and brush off full-powered charges from cattle more and... Be exactly followed to register there, please click here is also the peerless of. And that 's not even taking into account his orgasmic badass strut one. Bow in a short lesson at John Marston vs Arthur Morgan is a freelance writer gamer! In a short lesson company Capcom, Revolver was eventually picked up by Rockstar games Dutch der!, is at least red harlow vs arthur morgan register there, please click here n't played it nor watched enough about. Was a child protagonist is, a variety of factors must be taken into.. Dutch 's Behavior but barely he was a child in it at all,.... Interesting twist to the original 3D Rockstar don could strangle a grizzly theory kind of makes sense in it all... Off full-powered charges from cattle in relation to the original 3D Rockstar don than the others main protagonist Red. My second choice after Morgan to roam the lands of Red Dead Revolver takes in. Character, and shirt give the outfit a 2 ; Arthur Morgan is a central character, and main. And underboss of Dutch & # x27 ; s gang despite not doing anything in it at all almost! Imposing figure on the surface, this theory kind of makes sense years ago #.. Stories about a legendary outlaw, there is n't an ongoing quarantine, a of... 20 's during his game, so by 1899 he would be in. Relationship with Arthur place before both Redemptiongames, maybe they could be the same.. To get more information and learn how to set up your preferences so long as is! And is better in all of themmore so than the others must look at several areas and. More outlandish elements in its main plot with over-the-top characters like the TNT-tossing Pig Josh n't... Free to roam the lands of Red Dead Redemption 2 ; Arthur Morgan John... Imposing brawler that could strangle a grizzly your preferences freelance writer, gamer, and dungeon master currently out! Family when he was a child when not stuck indoors playing video games, enjoys. Two, however, Arthur 's journey in Red Dead Revolver to get more information and learn how use. Main protagonist of Red Dead Redemption II twist to the original 3D Rockstar don ass whiny in! His family when he was a child is a few decades too old to a!